Over the past few years I’ve noticed more and more of my colleagues in the emergency department using speech recognition (SR) software to dictate their notes rather than type them. Although I consider myself a technophile and I love experimenting with new technologies that could allow me to work more effectively, I resisted jumping on the SR bandwagon for a couple of reasons.
Firstly, I had convinced myself that I was proficient enough at typing that SR software was simply unnecessary. I can type at approximately 80 words-per-minute (wpm) with a high degree of accuracy and didn’t think that SR software would provide much of an advantage beyond what I was already doing. (If you’re curious to check your own typing speed you can test it here: https://www.typingtest.com/test.html)
The other major reason I was reluctant to try it out, as silly as this may sound, is that I was self-conscious about having other people overhear me dictating. I can’t explain exactly why I felt this way. Was I worried that others would judge how I worded my HPI and MDM? Was I concerned that someone would overhear my plan and disagree with it? I can’t tell you for sure but there was something off-putting about verbalizing my documentation out loud.
I regret allowing these hangups to put me off of trying SR software for as long as I did because it has truly been a game-changer for me. Little did I realize that today’s SR software can accurately dictate twice as fast as I can type. According to Nuance Communications Inc., a manufacturer of Dragon Medical software, voice dictation averages 150 words-per-minute.1 Regarding the concern about other people overhearing me while I dictate, I initially dealt with this by seeking out secluded locations where I could dictate in private. After a while, though, I realized that dictating in a room with others doesn’t really bother me like I thought it would. When I finally fully embraced SR dictation software I found that I was completing my charts in a fraction of the time that I had previously. Since integrating it into my practice I can’t imagine working without it.
HOW ACCURATE IS SR SOFTWARE?
I haven’t been able to find much literature looking at the accuracy of SR software in an emergency department setting. A study done by Goss et al2 reviewed a random sample of 100 notes dictated by attending emergency physicians using SR software. They found that 71% of notes contained errors or some sort. 15% of the charts contained one or more critical errors, meaning they could have affected providers’ decisions about patient care. It’s important to point out that the notes that were analyzed in this study were from 2012. I imagine that SR technology has evolved significantly since this study took place.
NUANCE DRAGON MEDICAL VS M*MODAL
There seem to be 2 market leaders in the medical SR software industry: Nuance Dragon Medical and M*Modal. I’ve had the opportunity to use the SR software made by each company while on shifts in the emergency department. While they have both have created remarkable products that will dramatically improve the efficiency of your workflow, if I had to choose one to work with on a daily basis it would be the software made by M*Modal. Their software seemed to have an edge when it came to accuracy, especially when it came to recognizing obscure medical terminology.
TIPS FOR USING SR SOFTWARE
- Enunciate clearly — While SR software has become remarkably good at deciphering my mumblings that tend to occur towards the end of my shift, there’s only so much you can expect from it. Enunciate clearly to minimize the number of times that you’ll have to go back to correct misspellings.
- Don’t speak too quickly — Another limitation of any SR software is the speed at which it can accurately detect your speech. As long as you speak at a normal conversational speed, or even slightly faster, the software will have no trouble following along. If you start speak like the Micro Machines guy the software will likely struggle to keep up.
- Minimize ambient noise — Another thing that really impresses me with the current SR technology is the ability of it to filter out ambient noise. That being said, it will occasionally pick up surrounding voices, so the less ambient noise, the better.
START USING ASAP
If you have access to SR software and aren’t already using it, try it out on your next shift. If your department hasn’t integrated it into your EMR, talk to your administrators about doing so. It’s well worth the investment and will improve the productivity and well-being for everyone in the department.
Do you already use SR software? Do you find it as helpful as I do? Let me know at theefficientmd@gmail.com
- https://www.nuance.com/content/dam/nuance/en_us/collateral/healthcare/demo/dmo-nuance-dragon-medical-infographic-en-us.pdf
- https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27435949
Good post and I’m glad to see that this site exists. We need more of this type of stuff. Keep it up!
Thanks for the comment, Bill! I’m glad you find it helpful.